Happy Hanukkah!
Posted: Dec Wed 01, 2010 2:41 pm
To any of the members out there that celebrate it, Happy Hanukkah!
Welcome to the Subsonic Radio Forums
https://forums.subsonicradio.com/
I actually meant to use the word "maligned", Len90, not "misaligned" (I blame it on the cold for the vocab error); however, I did enjoy your explanation a great deal. I meant to use "maligned" because it gets treated like the lesser holiday with Christmas being in the same month.Len90 wrote:To all my fellow menorah lighters, I wish you all a happy and healthy Hanukkah.
Mindflipper: You really are correct. It is very often under-appreciated to the point where people forget about it. The misalignment can easily be explained though! Hanukkah, like all other jewish holidays, is based on the hebrew calendar. The days per month in the Hebrew calendar is fewer than the days per month in the Gregorian Calendar. Because of this, when a Jewish leap year occurs there is an extra month added in as opposed to the extra day added into the Gregorian calendar. This year, 5771, is a Jewish leap year and there will be an extra month added in. That means Hanukkah will fall out around the time of christmas next year. Remember, the Jewish new year usually occurs sometime September, so he extra Hebrew month will be during the middle to end of August 2011.
LOL it's okay. It does feel that way and you are 100% correct.mindflipper wrote:I actually meant to use the word "maligned", Len90, not "misaligned" (I blame it on the cold for the vocab error); however, I did enjoy your explanation a great deal. I meant to use "maligned" because it gets treated like the lesser holiday with Christmas being in the same month.Len90 wrote:To all my fellow menorah lighters, I wish you all a happy and healthy Hanukkah.
Mindflipper: You really are correct. It is very often under-appreciated to the point where people forget about it. The misalignment can easily be explained though! Hanukkah, like all other jewish holidays, is based on the hebrew calendar. The days per month in the Hebrew calendar is fewer than the days per month in the Gregorian Calendar. Because of this, when a Jewish leap year occurs there is an extra month added in as opposed to the extra day added into the Gregorian calendar. This year, 5771, is a Jewish leap year and there will be an extra month added in. That means Hanukkah will fall out around the time of christmas next year. Remember, the Jewish new year usually occurs sometime September, so he extra Hebrew month will be during the middle to end of August 2011.
You're not terribly far off since both are drastically different in terms of celebration/importance than they were 100 years ago. Before the 50's or so Hanukkah was like the Hebrew version of saint swithin's day, mostly known but not celebrated and Christmas, from a historical standpoint, is considered a sort of marketing tool since the traditions and so forth are very close to the pagan holiday Saturnalia, and most of the modern traditions are very different from the past. I do miss the notion that bad children would be kidnapped by a black spanish midget (yes, that is the precursor to what the elf legend is).mindflipper wrote:I actually meant to use the word "maligned", Len90, not "misaligned" (I blame it on the cold for the vocab error); however, I did enjoy your explanation a great deal. I meant to use "maligned" because it gets treated like the lesser holiday with Christmas being in the same month.Len90 wrote:To all my fellow menorah lighters, I wish you all a happy and healthy Hanukkah.
Mindflipper: You really are correct. It is very often under-appreciated to the point where people forget about it. The misalignment can easily be explained though! Hanukkah, like all other jewish holidays, is based on the hebrew calendar. The days per month in the Hebrew calendar is fewer than the days per month in the Gregorian Calendar. Because of this, when a Jewish leap year occurs there is an extra month added in as opposed to the extra day added into the Gregorian calendar. This year, 5771, is a Jewish leap year and there will be an extra month added in. That means Hanukkah will fall out around the time of christmas next year. Remember, the Jewish new year usually occurs sometime September, so he extra Hebrew month will be during the middle to end of August 2011.
Oh... sorry try again.Jacca5660 wrote:Santa as we know it is a German tradition. NOT SPANISH!! Do you just put stuff out there to see if you can bull you way through it?? Christmas as we know it has always been either a commercial holiday or a day of drunken debauchery, at least in the English tradition. The church tried to ban Christmas for these reasons!