Page 1 of 1
Disneyland marriage proposal
Posted: Jul Wed 08, 2009 9:48 pm
by agingerbugg
Just stumbled upon this, what a lucky girl. This is so awesome.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IpojZ0COU3Y
Posted: Jul Wed 08, 2009 10:18 pm
by MadEye
It was a fake planned by Disney. It was criticized at another forum and it was confirmed that Disney was behind it. It was interesting though...
Posted: Jul Wed 08, 2009 10:56 pm
by MmeLeota
lol! It looks staged, but it's cute anyway...
Posted: Jul Fri 10, 2009 9:02 am
by Dr. Ravenscroft
I turned it off right about when the guy started singing after the first woman singer. Looked staged from the word go. how are you going to film that from that high of an angle without Disney's permission to be on top of the buildings. Plus multiple cameras???? My brother is the only other person I know that shoots with multiple angles when filming at Disney.
Posted: Jul Fri 10, 2009 10:33 am
by cousininmiami
Yup, looked fake to me too.
Posted: Jul Fri 10, 2009 7:48 pm
by Jacca5660
That's not real!
Posted: Jul Fri 10, 2009 10:00 pm
by momeja
Ah, if only real life could be like life in a musical production...
Btw, did anyone notice that one of the guys sitting on the curb looks strikingly like Ben Stiller? I wonder if he directed it.
Posted: Jul Fri 10, 2009 10:18 pm
by Clusty
Hah, I turned it off when they started singing. The start was somewhat believable(if you ignored the logistics of getting a camera that high), but then it just went downhill.
Posted: Jul Sat 11, 2009 10:01 pm
by aparadissis
They lost me at the good camera angels and good audio. If it was spontaneous, then the quality should have been much worse.
Posted: Jul Sun 12, 2009 4:07 pm
by bigthunderlover
If that happened to me, and my boyfriend started signing and dancing, I would be embarrassed. Or id' be like where's my boyfriend and what did you do with him? haha! Yah if it wasnt a set up then the boyfriend worked for disney and had the whole thing set up for his girl. very possible if it were true and they met in that spot. Cuz who meets there love in disneyland besides the castmembers themselves?
Posted: Jul Sun 12, 2009 6:57 pm
by spodie
Yeah, it looks pretty fake to me. My first clue was that the girl was miked, and it's not just some sort of Wal Mart recording device - she had to have been hooked up almost as much as an actor in a movie would be. My second clue was the staged singing and dancing, and then my third clue was the way they both acted when she said 'yes'. Now, I've been engaged approximately...0 times, but they didn't look like a couple who had just gotten engaged. He high-fived people while she just stood there, and then they hugged.
It looks like some kind of promotion Disney ran to encorporate their 'Celebrate Today' theme.
Posted: Jul Wed 15, 2009 10:55 pm
by DisBeamer
aparadissis wrote:They lost me at the good camera angels and good audio. If it was spontaneous, then the quality should have been much worse.
I have to say I was amused they figured the multiple cameras part was believable. Mind you, I know several people who 'fell for it', so to speak, so maybe I'm just overly cynical.
Posted: Jul Thu 16, 2009 8:25 am
by momeja
DisBeamer wrote:aparadissis wrote:They lost me at the good camera angels and good audio. If it was spontaneous, then the quality should have been much worse.
I have to say I was amused they figured the multiple cameras part was believable. Mind you, I know several people who 'fell for it', so to speak, so maybe I'm just overly cynical.
Do you think Disney really intended people to be fooled? After all, how often does a marriage proposal include a musical chorus?
Posted: Jul Thu 16, 2009 3:44 pm
by DisBeamer
momeja wrote:DisBeamer wrote:aparadissis wrote:They lost me at the good camera angels and good audio. If it was spontaneous, then the quality should have been much worse.
I have to say I was amused they figured the multiple cameras part was believable. Mind you, I know several people who 'fell for it', so to speak, so maybe I'm just overly cynical.
Do you think Disney really intended people to be fooled? After all, how often does a marriage proposal include a musical chorus?
From what I read about their 'admission' it was viral marketing, I have to believe they figured people would be fooled initially, at least, and entirely, at best. I believe the intent of it as marketing is to suggest things like that happen in Disneyland. And, to be fair, I imagine if you threw enough money at them, you
could make it happen, but it's not something they're going to help you do for free, which is what I believe is implied by the 'Disney is magical' angle. The feeling of it is "This can happen here!", and that's disingenuous, to me.
I <3 Disney, but I can't say as I think they think all that highly of their fans' intelligence, to be blunt.
It is a cute commercial, though. And props to them for admitting it was fake when pressed on the issue.